References / Published research

Field shape changes which response appears, and no shape is proven best

Published research
The report records the measured shape of each pulse because shape changes how a field acts on cells. It doesn't rank shapes, because no study has shown one shape works best overall.
Where it appears in the report: Waveform Shape and Timing, Rise / Fall Time, Slew Rate

The evidence

Only a few studies compare field shapes directly. In one, rat bone-forming cells were exposed to sine, triangular, square and sawtooth fields at the same frequency (50 Hz) and strength (1.8 mT). Each shape favored a different response: the square field made the cells multiply but not mature, the sine field slowed growth but raised mineralization, and the triangular field gave the strongest bone-forming activity. In another, a narrow symmetrical square pulse increased the stiffness of healing rabbit bone as the lopsided pulse used in clinical bone stimulators did, and the authors credited the fast, narrow part of the pulse. Both are laboratory studies, in cells and in animals, not trials in people. No clinical trial compares shapes, and reviews note that most studies don't describe their signal well enough to compare. One more point matters when reading these papers: a study's "square" or "triangular" names the shape of the field. A device that drives its coil with a square voltage produces a field that ramps, closer to a sawtooth or triangle, because a coil can't change its current instantly. That is why the report shows the measured field shape beside the shape the manufacturer documents.

Primary sources

  • Zhou J, Wang JQ, Ge BF, Ma XN, Ma HP, Xian CJ, Chen KM. Different electromagnetic field waveforms have different effects on proliferation, differentiation and mineralization of osteoblasts in vitro. Bioelectromagnetics. 2014;35(1):30-38. PMID 23775573. view
  • Pienkowski D, Pollack SR, Brighton CT, Griffith NJ. Comparison of asymmetrical and symmetrical pulse waveforms in electromagnetic stimulation. J Orthop Res. 1992;10(2):247-255. PMID 1740743. view
  • Mansourian M, Shanei A. Evaluation of Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Effects: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on Highlights of Two Decades of Research In Vitro Studies. Biomed Res Int. 2021;2021:6647497. view